Young Adult Fiction equals “Dumbed Down”?

05, Jul 2013 by KristiCook">KristiCook in Featured,Market Trends,Writing Business     , , ,   3 Comment

DunceHatHeader

Every year when I begin teaching a commercial fiction class for adults, I have at least one student who, when we start discussing Young Adult/Teen fiction, asks something to the effect of “YA fiction is just dumbed down writing, right?”

I can’t tell you how disheartening this is.  Let me state it boldly for the record:

Young Adult fiction is NOT “regular” fiction simply “dumbed down” (or simplified) for teen readers.  

I wish I didn’t have to write a post about this, but unfortunately I think it’s necessary.  I’ll say it loud and clear:  if you think that teen readers can only “comprehend” simplified, basic prose, then you should not be writing young adult fiction.  Believe it or not, teen readers are some of the most sophisticated readers out there.  Keep in mind that, unlike most adults, they are regularly reading “literature,” courtesy of…you know…school.  Austen, Shakespeare, Joyce, Kafka, Hemingway…they’re reading it.  They have to.  And trust me, they are far more familiar with complicated prose, metaphors, similes, and other literary devices than most adults.  I mean, when was the last time you sat down and read James Joyce for fun?!

So throw away the notion that teens won’t “get” sophisticated prose.   But that isn’t to say that all YA fiction is complicated, “literary” prose.  Just like fiction targeting adult audiences, there is a range in writing styles in YA fiction.  Yes, some YA novels are pretty simplistic (Twilight, anyone?).   Sometimes it’s a matter of voice–the way a protagonist speaks and thinks.  But other YA novels feature more “complicated” prose and literary devices.  One great example is Maggie Stievater’s fabulous The Scorpio Races–in fact, I would say that all of Stievater’s books feature some beautiful prose.  Other good examples are Carrie Ryan’s Forest of Hands and Teeth series, Elizabeth Wein’s Code Name Verity, and Ruta Sepetys’ Between Shades of Gray.   Anything by John Green or David Levithan feature sophisticated, often lyrical prose, as well.

Just like adult fiction, young adult fiction offers a range of novels from pure commercial to award-winning literature, but none of it is “dumbed down.”  To suggest that it is is an insult to YA readers and writers alike.

[author] [author_image timthumb=’on’]http://howtowriteshop.loridevoti.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/KristiColumn.jpg[/author_image] [author_info]Kristi’s YA debut, HAVEN, was released by Simon Pulse in Feb. 2011. She also writes adult fiction (historical romance) as Kristina Cook and Kristi Astor. Visit her online at www.kristi-cook.com. [/author_info] [/author]

 

3 thoughts on “Young Adult Fiction equals “Dumbed Down”?”

  1. Martha B. says:

    Well said! And YA just keeps maturing and growing even finer!

  2. Zara says:

    I really appreciated this post. Some people just don’t understand that teens can understand complex writing. I’m a teen myself, so I find it frustrating, but this made me happy.

  3. mik says:

    I’m coming from the opposite point of view. I’ve gotten turned-off from reading a lot of YA because the WRITING felt ham-fisted. The kind of writing that would get laughed at had it entered an adult market. It’s not an issue with the subject or the characters, but the WAY they’re written. I don’t know if maybe I just had the bad luck to read YA writers that were perhaps still raw in their writing craft, but this is what really frustrates me about the YA I’ve read so far.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *